• Sarah Michelle Gellar paid tribute to her co-star Michelle Trachtenberg on 27 February
  • Trachtenberg was found dead in her apartment at age 39 on 26 February
  • The actresses played sisters on Buffy The Vampire Slayer
Sarah Michelle Gellar Buffy reboot Michelle Trachtenberg
Sarah Michelle Gellar at the Critics Choice Awards 2025. Credit: IMAGO/ Future Image

A day after her death, Sarah Michelle Gellar paid tribute to her co-star and friend Michelle Trachtenberg. The two first met on the set of the ABC soap opera All My Children and went on to star in the cult classic Buffy The Vampire Slayer together. Trachtenberg played Gellar’s younger sister on the show.

Reports surfaced on 26 February that Trachtenberg was “in talks” to reprise her role on Buffy, but Gellar has not commented on those rumors.

Read More: Stars React to Michelle Trachtenberg Passing Away

In an Instagram post, Gellar posted a tribute to her on-screen sister with old photos of the two. Previous Buffy co-stars who have paid tribute to the late actress are James Marsters, Emma Caufield, and David Boreanaz.

You can read Gellar’s post below.

With her tribute out, here is what the Buffy star said about Trachtenberg.

What did Sarah Michelle Gellar write about Michelle Trachtenberg?

Sarah Michelle Gellar Michelle Trachtenberg Buffy reboot
Sarah Michelle Gellar as Buffy and Michelle Trachtenberg as Dawn Summers on Buffy. Credit: IMAGO/ Capital Pictures

Gellar appeared to move away from a generic tribute, and seemed to write a quote she said to Trachtenberg in the caption. The actress wrote: “Michelle, listen to me. Listen. I love you. I will always love you. The hardest thing in this world, is to live in it. I will be brave. I will live… for you”.

The caption, however sad it is, pays a beautiful tribute to a friendship of over two decades. Gellar’s photo slide included photos of them on-set of Buffy, at events, and hanging out in more recent years.

The dynamic of the two captivated Buffy fans on-screen as Buffy worked to fiercely protect her younger sister from Supernatural danger. On the show, Dawn was introduced and was revealed to be a supernatural entity The Key, made to open portals to other dimensions.

A.K.A releasing demons and creating chaos on Earth!

Gellar reshared the photos to her Instagram Stories, documenting the ladies’ friendship over the years.

Did fans react to Sarah Michelle Gellar’s tribute to Michelle Trachtenberg?

Fans of Buffy flooded the comments with support for Gellar’s post.

One fan wrote, “My heart. That Last picture…”

The last picture showed Gellar and Trachtenberg smiling with the late actress Shannen Doherty, who died in July 2024 of breast cancer. Gellar and Doherty were long-time friends. Doherty rose to province also in the nineties for her role in the drama Beverly Hills, 902010.

Sarah Michelle Gellar and Michelle Trachtenberg
One fan pointed out the last picture of Gellar, Doherty and Trachtenberg. Credit: Instagram

Another commenter sent condolences to Gellar for her loss. They wrote: “I’m so sorry honey.”

Michelle Trachtenberg and Sarah Michelle Gellar
One fan gave condolences to Sarah Michelle Gellar. Credit: Instagram

Meanwhile, other commentators paid their respects to both actresses.

Sarah Michelle Gellar and Michelle Trachtenberg
A commentor paid tribute to Michelle Trachtenberg and gave condolences to Sarah Michelle Gellar. Credit: Instagram

One fan focused on Gellar’s loss, writing: “I’m so sorry for your loss Sarah.”

Sarah Michelle Gellar Michelle Trachtenberg
A fan said they were sorry for Sarah Michelle Gellar’s loss. Credit: Instagram

Rest in peace, Trachtenberg, and we hope Gellar heals from this loss.

author avatar
Sophie Humphrey
Sophie Humphrey is a freelance writer and journalist. Sophie has seven years experience in journalism and has a keen interest in pop culture and entertainment. Sophie has worked for the likes of Time Out London, The Upcoming and Screen rant.